Home
Home
  
   
Introduction
Introduction

  
  
Technical Options
Technical
Options
  
Policy Tools
Policy
Tools
  
Actual Practices
Actual
Practices

Theory v. Practice
Theory v.
Practice

Conclusion
Conclusion

  
  

Biodiversity and Species Protection
the economic perspective


Convention
on International
Trade in
Endangered
Species

(CITES)

Illegal Products


The international community has also recognized the problem of endangered species.  In 1973, 21 countries gathered together to address this issue.  The meeting culminated in the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES), effective July 1, 1975.  This international agreement instituted a trade ban approach to curtail international trade of species on the endangered list.  Today, approximately 145 countries are party to the CITES agreement.  The Department of the State estimates that illegal trafficking in endangered species market can run into the billions of dollars, second only to the narcotics industry.

CITES protects both plants and animals that face extinction as a result of over-exploitation through the international trade market.   The policy instrument used in CITES is the traditional command-and-control method, using import and export permits to regulate the trade activity.   The United Nations Environment Program administers CITES; however, the member countries must enforce the treaty provisions locally.  In the United States, the Office of Management Authority administers CITES, and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service provides technical support.

The following international NGOs also support the CITES agreement:

  • Fauna and Flora International (FFI)
  • The World Conservation Union (IUCN)
  • Trade Records Analysis of Flora and Fauna in Commerce (TRAFFIC)
  • World Conservation Monitoring Centre (WCMC)
  • World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF)

Key features of CITES

  • When countries agree that a species faces extinction as a result of international trade, the members may list the species (similar to the ESA listing).  For CITES, three categories distinguish the degree of endangerment:
     
    • Appendix I status:  This listing provides the greatest amount of protection for a species.   This status seeks to eliminate all trade in the endangered species themselves, and also in products made from the species.

      Species that have an Appendix I status include apes, many moneys, elephants, tigers, whales, parrots, sea turtles, the rhinoceros, the giant panda, and others.

    • Appendix II status:  This listing allows trade to continue, but the member countries must continuously monitor the trade activity to ensure that the species remains viable.   This listing status provides for a permitting system to regulate the trade in these species.
       
    • Appendix III status:  This listing provides the least protection; species are listed in this category if one of the member countries seeks assistance from other member countries in controlling or monitoring trade for the species.
  • Member countries meet once every two years to review the listed species, and determine whether new listing statuses are necessary to protect certain plants and animals.  This meeting is called the "Conference of the Parties" (COP).
  • Non-governmental organizations representing conservation, animal welfare, trade, zoological, and scientific interests, may attend the biennial COPs, as well.  The NGOs are not allowed to vote during the meeting, but they are allowed to voice their positions.

Does CITES protect endangered species?

Like the ESA, CITES enjoys success for some species.  For instance, the trade in African elephant parts diminished quickly during the late 1980's, after CITES gave the elephant an Appendix I status.  However, this success was in large part due to the public awareness campaign that accompanied this listing.  The demand for elephant products in Europe and in the United States dropped to such a low point that illegal trafficking was no longer lucrative.  On the other hand, trade in tiger parts continues to threaten the species.  Although the tiger also received an Appendix I listing, and a public awareness campaign, this species faces the continued threat of illegal trade.  Because tiger parts find themselves in medicines and other such products, it is more difficult to catch the flow of these products through countries.

For more information, please see visit the CITES homepage at:
   http://www.wcmc.org.uk:80/CITES/english/index.html

 


The School of Public and Environmental Affairs
Copyright 1999 Indiana University Bloomington
Comments: kenricha@indiana.edu